Sponsor
A Prairie Home Companion with Garrison Keillor

Post to the Host
GK responds to queries on topics from childbearing to potato salad, with a little bookstore fetish in between.

Send your own post to the host.
Here's your chance to ask GK your most pressing questions—about the writing life, the radio life, Lake Wobegon, Guy Noir, whatever you like. Also, feel free to send feedback about the show. Honest comments and criticism are always welcome!


Add this blog to your web site





Post to the Host:
Why isn't the show broadcast on one of the TV cable channels like some other radio shows are? Love the show, would love to watch you in action also (like the movie — which I have seen 5 times).

Beth G.

--

Thanks for the thought, Beth, but my experience is that when you bring TV into the picture, you are dealing with very intense, nervous people who talk loud, and TV sort of takes over. TV people are still under the illusion that theirs is the dominant broadcast medium. Wherever you have TV and radio operating under one roof, TV is all spread out on the main floor and radio is in the basement. But radio is the medium of people on the move, in cars, on bikes, walking, running, and TV is the medium of people in nursing homes and prisons. Big TV fans in penal institutions: check it out. So here at our little radio show, we think, "Why take on the grief of being shoved around by a bunch of heavies just so we can be seen in Sing Sing?" Life is good. Why take on troubles you don't need?

Permalink» | Comments (10) »



Post to the Host:
I wonder if you have ever thought you might publish all of the essays in The Old Scout in book fashion?

I know hundreds of people here who would rush out and buy copies. Please, if you do this, don't edit a word!

Patience W.
Shaftesbury, England

I don't know what the point of book publication is, Patience, if the entire body of newspaper columns is archived online at salon.com. Anybody who wishes can read any of them free. The only reason to put them in a book is to have the chance to rewrite them and I don't know if I have the stomach for that or not. They're short newspaper columns, 750 words, not essays and not letters, and I think the only reason to put them in a book is personal vanity, which goodness knows I have plenty of, but am not sure that a collection of hastily-written columns would serve my vanity all that well. But I do intend to publish a collection of sonnets, including the Christmas sonnet I did on the show tonight (Dec. 20).

"The Old Scout" articles are also available here.

Permalink» | Comments (4) »



Post to the Host:
What was the name of the book you are reading that you mentioned on last night's (12/13) show?

Dick B.
Oxford, MS

--

The English Major, by Jim Harrison. A terrific funny picaresque novel by a great American man of letters. I've read many of his poems on The Writers Almanac.

Permalink» | Comments (0) »



Post to the Host:
I'm interested to know if you've ever written a song about Lake Wobegon. The closing line about strong women, good looking men, and above average children has the makings of a classic country tune. I'd love to hear the tune if there is one from older shows.

David M.
Ballston Spa, NY

--

There have been a number, David. There's the "Lake Wobegon Hymn" ("Morning light, soft and bright, Wobegon reveals. Early frost all across farm and woods and fields") with music by Dvořák. Lake Wobegon High School has the Alma Mater. There's "One More Spring In Minnesota (To Come Upon Lake Wobegon)" with music by Peter Ostroushko. "Sons of Knute Christmas Dance and Dinner" is one we still do every year. There's "Slow Days of Summer" and "Summer in Lake Wobegon" and "Song of the Exiles" and then there's a song about the "Lake Wobegon Trail" which wends its way through Stearns County. A bike trail. Here are the links, if you're interested.

My Minnesota Home
Lake Wobegon Hymn (audio)
Alma Mater (audio in the News from Lake Wobegon)
One More Spring in Minnesota
Sons of Knute Christmas Dance and Dinner (audio)
Slow Days of Summer
Summer in Lake Wobegon
Song of the Exiles (audio in the News from Lake Wobegon)
Lake Wobegon Bike Trail

Permalink» | Comments (3) »



Dear Mr. Keillor,
I recently saw your show in NYC on December 6th. It was really wonderful! It made for a great day and it would have been a REALLY great day, had I not been plagued by hiccups.

Then it occurred to me — when a mere 17 year old girl from New Jersey gets hiccups, it's no big deal. But what about when YOU finds you are having repeated spasmodic contractions of the diaphragm while ON AIR?

Regards,
Julia

--

Hasn't happened to me yet, Julia, and thanks for raising the specter in my mind. I guess I'd just signal the band and they'd play something loud for awhile and I'd put my head under water. On Saturday night, I started coughing, but a stage manager dashed out with a bottle of water and I was okay. There is something about adrenaline that suppresses these problems, I find. I've started the show with a blazing headache and pretty soon it's all gone. I've been sick to my stomach and doing the show clears that up. And I have never had to pee during a show. Never. Isn't that interesting? So the cure to your hiccup problem, Julia, is to put yourself into serious trouble — like, doing a show in New York — and that'll take care of it.

Permalink» | Comments (5) »



Post to the Host:
A young waitress last week asked my wife and me, "What can I get you guys?" She used the reference fourteen times during the course of the meal and, being an English major, I found it inappropriate. Do you? I'm wondering if getting your P.O.E.M. shirt to wear in public might forewarn people to be more aware of their people skills. What is your opinion?

Lee N.
Niagara Falls, New York

--

The Professional Organization of English Majors shirt (short- or long-sleeves) is useful for all sorts of things but it isn't likely to change your waitress's word usage. Had she said it to me and my wife, I think we'd have been amused. This is how she'd talk to her friends — "You guys want to hang out?" — and her addressing us older people in that familiar way doesn't offend me at all. Au contraire, mon confrere. It's like the old bartender who used to call me "pal" though he didn't know my name. It was sweet of him, and sweetness trumps correctness. So says me, sweetheart.

Permalink» | Comments (16) »



Post to the Host:
Please don't make jokes about juggling cats, swinging cats by the tail, etc. It's offensive, and there are probably cat detractors out there who could be inspired.

Richard

--

You're referring to a sound-effects joke in which I described a juggler who juggled a cat, a hot toaster, and an alarm clock while jumping on a pogo stick and playing a trumpet. I think the chance of a public radio listener juggling a cat as a result of hearing that is rather slim. About the same as the likelihood of someone juggling a hot toaster. But next time, instead of a cat, I'll have him juggle a horse.

Permalink» | Comments (7) »



Hello Garrison,
Wanted to let you know,that for many of us that work at the South Pole Station, your weekly show, that is steamed in, is one of the things that let us feel like we are still part of world we left behind. PHC is one of those things that keep us tethered to the world we love, but yet, is so far away.


Thanks again,
Dennis D.
ICECUBE project
UW–Madison

--

Summering in the Antarctic, are you, Dennis? I'll bet it is idyllic. I grew up reading about the famous expeditions to the South Pole and the heroism of Amundsen, Shackleton, Byrd, and especially the Scott expedition that died on the return trip, but I'm sure that conditions have improved and you're not huddled in pup tents chewing on half-roasted sled dog haunch. I'd love to come see the station and will do a show for you ABSOLUTELY FREE if you will persuade the authorities to fly me down there. I have a week free in January. A perfect time to get away from the northern tundra. I would need to bring my older brother, the retired engineer in Madison, who craves a trip to the Antarctic, and I would, of course, bring a musician or two. And a small technical crew so that we could record the whole thing for broadcast. I guess we're talking about a 30-hour flight, right? No problem. We can do it. Are there people at the Station who can sing or tell jokes or tell stories? I wouldn't want to do a show that has meteorologists yakking about wind patterns or geologists — geology puts me right to sleep. See what you can do about this. You might need to stage a violent overthrow and take hostages — and if you demand PHC as a condition for their release, I will be on a plane pronto. Roger. Over.

Permalink» | Comments (19) »



Dear Mr. Keillor—
I am listening to the rerun of your November 29th show from Cincinnati and in your greetings you wish a happy 102nd birthday to Mildred Glick in Hollywood. I believe she is my mother's old friend, my "Aunt" Micky, my sister's namesake. I've lost track of her over the years and would love to touch base with her and her children. I can't believe there would be two Mildred Glicks in Hollywood. Is it possible for you to put me in touch with the person who sent the birthday wishes?

I had to laugh when I heard the age because my mother always said Aunt Micky lied about her age. I celebrated her "50th" with her in California with her, then, 5th husband, my Uncle Fred. People are amazed when I tell them the story of my two "aunts", one on the east coast and one on the west coast, who each had been married five times and their last husband was the same man.

Many thanks,
Suzanne R.
Birchrunville, PA

--

Those greetings, my dear Suzanne, are scribbled on scraps of paper by people in the audience and when I'm done reading them, I drop them on the floor and they're collected by a stagehand who throws them away. So we don't know any more than what you heard on the air, and probably that was all that was written on the slip of paper anyway. If anyone reads this who knows MILDRED GLICK OF HOLLYWOOD M*I*L*D*R*E*D**G*L*I*C*K *OF**H*O*L*L*Y*W*O*O*D paging MILDRED GLICK OF HOLLYWOOD and they'd like to put her in touch with you, we will pass that information on. A woman who married five times is worth your getting to know better. Hope spring eternal.

Permalink» | Comments (2) »



Post to the Host:
Please expound on how you selected the name Guy Noir. Could it be an allusion to "Dark Man"? or "The Shadow"?

Jac B.
League City, TX

--

Back when I was an English major in college, I was able to expound at the drop of a hat, Jac, and I could've written a thousand words on this or almost any other subject, including books I had never read, but I've lost that ability to tease out allusions and draw parallels and make them dance, and all I can tell you now is that I chose the name Noir because the sketch is based on film noir and the name Guy because it's a French name that in English simply means "man" though nowadays some people use it to refer to women too. That's it. Back to you.

Permalink» | Comments (4) »



"Prairie Home Companion" epitomizes everything wrong with:


  1. NPR

  2. Garrison Keillor, and

  3. Midwestern America in general.

When this flavorless, humorless comedy, featuring bland, slow-paced, hokey, corn-fed themes, doesn't actually lull the listener into a lobotomized glaze characteristic of the entire region south of International Falls between the Mississippi and the Rockies, it manages to infuriate for its sheer maddening unfunniness. Keillor and his crew of edgeless, hee-yuking goobers are the flat beer, Muzak, and unsalted chips of an outmoded radio world best left to nostalgic misremembrance or (better yet) glass-eyed senility.

Spare me this tripe. I'm not dead yet.

— Critical Miami

Permalink» | Comments (82) »



Post to the Host:
How do you react to unpleasant people?

Paul C.
Rochester, NY

--

I meet so few of them that it always comes as a surprise. Drivers on the freeway can be dreadful, of course — tailgating, honking at you because you eased in front of them and cut them off, zooming around you in rage — but you steadily ignore them, of course, nothing else to be done. Once in a blue moon I encounter unpleasant drunks and there, again, you simply listen to them blather and make pleasant murmurs in reply and slip away as gracefully as possible. Then there is the occasional person who feels the need to tell you that he does not care for the radio show, or for my singing, and never could understand why others do, and this person (I think) has the right to make his statement and be respected for it. The unpleasantness that is a problem is that of one's friends — it must be dealt with, and sometimes the friendship is lost over it. And then there is one's own unpleasantness, which is truly painful. One simply suffers over it. I don't know how to avoid it. It simply crops up. The art of management — of directing people, of instructing them, of rejecting some of their ideas — is not easily learned. I think I am ever pleasant to strangers, but as to people I know well, staff, guests, friends, family — I don't know. Yikes.

Permalink» | Comments (2) »



Post to the Host Archives

2009
November
October
August
June
May
April

2008
December
November
October
September
August
July
June
May
April
March
February
January

2007
December
November
October
September
August
July
June
May
April
March
February
January

2006
December
November
October
September
August
July
June
May
April
March
February
January

2005
December
November
October
September
August
July
June
May
April
March
February
January

2004
December
November
October
September
August
July
June
May
April
March
February
January

2003
December
November
October
September
August
July
June
May
March
February
January

2002
December
November
October
August
July
June
May
April
February
January

2001
December
November
October
August
July
June
May
April
February
January

2000
December
October
September
August
July
June
May
January

1999
November
September
August
May
April
February

1998
November
July
May
April
March
February
January

1997
December
November
October
September
August
July
June
May
April
March
February
January

1996
December



  • News/Talk
  • Music
  • Entertainment