Post to the Host
Host Garrison Keillor answers your questions about life, love, writing, authors, and of course, A Prairie Home Companion.
Ojibwe in Lake Wobegon?
May 13, 2008 | 7 Comments

Why have there been no reference to the Ojibwe people who lived, and always have, in the land where Lake Wobegon is set—mythically as well as geophysically? And why are no native voices captured in the multifarious cast of characters in Lake Wobegon? We have many excellent native musical groups too, some from Minnesota and nearby Wisconsin who have won NAMIES, who would make good listening for the folks across the country who enjoy the show.
Mi-iew Miigwech—many thanks—
Autumn's Mother
Carol Lee S.
The short answer is: the show is entertainment and native music is religious, the show is comedy and white people cannot do comedy about native people. We've had a few native musical groups on and they did not seem comfortable about performing as part of a variety show and the time constraints were rather brutal. The place to hear native music in all its glory is at a powwow which operates on a whole other sense of time. For better or worse, the show reflects the taste of the founder and that is far from all-inclusive.
7 Comments
|
Previous Post: |
Next Post: |
Post to the Host Archive
- The Lake Wobegon Effect
- Longevity
- Abdication vs. Retirement
- Our Lady of Perpetual Responsibility
- Memory
- Sarah Bellum
- Starting Over
- Do you get to laugh?
- Keep Looking Ahead
- Big City vs. Hometown
- Awful Timing for Love
- Write Funny
- Telling a Story
- Fathers and Daughters
- Big City Yearnings
- Performing in Public
- Visiting Denmark
- Breaking into Show Business
- Moving Back with Mom
- Surviving as a journalist
- Advice for a Competitive Campaign
- A Life-Changing Moment
- In Search of a Wedding Poem
- Trying to turn a passion into a profession
- Spring Break
- American Jokes
- Norwegian Immigration to Lake Wobegon
- One thing leads to another
- All Good Writing is Rewriting
- The Goodbye To Childhood You're On Your Own Now Ceremony
- Skiing in the Alps
- Competing against the young
- Finding confidence
- The value of public universities
- Ruining Lutefisk
- A Christmas Blizzard
- Memoirs
- How do I get noticed?
- Poetry and the Fairer Sex
- Developing a natural voice
- Pentecost
- Boycott
- Anonymous in the Big City
- Thanks to Ford
- Offended
- What happened to that "Sweet Biscuit Fiddle?"
- "Tom and Sally"
- NOTE FROM THE HOST
- SFX Lady??
- Missing The Old Scout
- Live in San Diego
- So Where's Sinclair?
- This is my first big trip away from home. Any advice for a first-time traveler?
- How come the house band is called The Shoe Band?
- October 21 Cinecast
- Getting into the Radio Business
- On the 12th Floor of the Acme Building...
- Going to the Big City!
- 73 Days of Summer Vacation
- Help with a Eulogy
- Where Do I Start?
- Fantasy League Whippets
- Clergywomen in Lake Wobegon
- The more you write, the better it gets
- The Voice
- A Note from GK about Retirement
- Low Self-Esteem
- Useless Degrees
- Car Bomb
- The Dog-Ears of Summer
- Dealing with Disappointment
- Rejection Letters
- English Majors Strike Again
- 7th Grade Report
- GK Responds to Cinecast Posts
Complete Post to the Host Archive
KQ | May 13, 2008 12:26 PM
I am confident in the honesty of Mr. Keillor's statement that native music does not fit into the format of PHC, and his candor regarding personal taste seems fair. One radio show cannot be all things to all people. GK can air whatever content he wants - he seems to be doing quite well in the current format. That said, I did cringe at the explanation "the show is entertainment and native music is religious" - are gospel songs, hymns and even occasional (hauntingly beautiful) Hebrew songs not a primary genre of musical faire at PHC?
As far as suggesting characters for inclusion in Lake Woebegon - well, I'm native to the Bay Area, where diversity is the norm and any place around here with only white people just seems weird. I'd love to see not only (perhaps) native people popping up from time to time, but also gay people(a gay family would be very cool), asians, hispanics, a whole blooming rainbow of diversity! After all, Minnesota is not unlike the rest of the country and immigrants did not quit arriving after the Norweigans got there...
Lake Woebegon, it seems to me, is a finite storytelling palette. The artist knows his colors and format and sticks to his strengths and talents. I (one of millions) admire and appreciate the result.
Robert | May 16, 2008 9:10 AM
American Indians have a wonderful sense of humor and a set of jokes not often heard outside the (tribe?). A humorous commentary or interview would fit nicely with PHC humor. As for music, a flute solo, non religious, such as Robert Mirabel does, would fit within the time constraints, and I'll bet your audience would love it.
B martin | May 17, 2008 5:43 PM
Good grief, a ficticious place on a comedy/varity show on the radio, and there are actually people out there who actualy wonder "what, no American Indians?" Geez...political correctness sure has turned our society into a bunch of glass half-empty, paranoid whiners. There are no ethnic working class elderly women of gypsy decent appearing in the Lake Wobogon segment either. Guess what, it's still funny and it's still entertaining. Get a grip.
Doug | May 23, 2008 4:16 PM
With due respect, you can do comedy about anything. Funny is funny.
Karen | May 27, 2008 7:55 PM
I love that someone asked the question about Natives since there are so many amazing talents from that area. Louise Erhdrich (sp?) is one who comes to mind. I know her poems have been highlighted on GK's literary piece. I'd love to hear her on the show... reading a poem or even getting into a skit using one of her poems that speaks to both her German and Indigenous roots... She is serious and introspective, yet humor could be a great way to expose the many "all-white crowd" to the complexity and beauty of the area from another voice and perspective.
CM Podulke | May 31, 2008 8:04 AM
It boggles my mind that a vehicle so associated with Minnesota culture, and yes, responsible for the image it produces, has no place for Anishinabe charachters. Get a grip indeed!
Beau, gwy | May 31, 2008 11:07 AM
I enjoy the PHC show very much, in fact I drove from Colorado to New Mexico to see the show today. I haven't thought about the show being all White. Interesting. Who would have thought that NASCAR would start to integrate before some NPR shows. Go figure. Yes, some Native songs are religious, some Caucasian songs are religious.....The Pow Wow comment is perhaps a little bit of a stereotype.