Post to the Host
Host Garrison Keillor answers your questions about life, love, writing, authors, and of course, A Prairie Home Companion.
June 11, 2007 | 11 Comments
Dear Mr. Keillor,
This week you shot a groundhog. Every week, it's the same darned thing. You think it's funny to have an animal die in some undignified way. I withdrew support from Hawaii Public Radio when I lived there because of your incessant humor about animal death and cruelty. Now I live in Montana.
I turn the show off as soon as the first animal dies in your monologue. You are a poor second to Jean Shepard if you cannot remedy your habit of killing animals with your humor. I heard you live when you visited Honolulu two or three years ago. I'm glad you refrained from animal jokes then. My wife and I were prepared to go ballistic in the audience.
Jerald C.
Eureka, MT
I have never shot an animal in my life, Mr. C., unlike most of your neighbors there in Montana. People in Lake Wobegon (and Montana) do sometimes shoot animals they consider pests, and that is what the pastor's wife did in the story I told on the show. It wasn't a joke; it was a detail in a story, same as the thunderclouds in the sky and the geese flying overhead honking. If you think that a storyteller should eliminate all violence and cruelty from stories, then you should perhaps address Stephen King or Cormac McCarthy. I do wonder about people who would "go ballistic" in an audience and it makes me wonder if maybe the days of live radio aren't numbered.
11 Comments
|
Previous Post: |
Next Post: |
Post to the Host Archive
- The Lake Wobegon Effect
- Longevity
- Abdication vs. Retirement
- Our Lady of Perpetual Responsibility
- Memory
- Sarah Bellum
- Starting Over
- Do you get to laugh?
- Keep Looking Ahead
- Big City vs. Hometown
- Awful Timing for Love
- Write Funny
- Telling a Story
- Fathers and Daughters
- Big City Yearnings
- Performing in Public
- Visiting Denmark
- Breaking into Show Business
- Moving Back with Mom
- Surviving as a journalist
- Advice for a Competitive Campaign
- A Life-Changing Moment
- In Search of a Wedding Poem
- Trying to turn a passion into a profession
- Spring Break
- American Jokes
- Norwegian Immigration to Lake Wobegon
- One thing leads to another
- All Good Writing is Rewriting
- The Goodbye To Childhood You're On Your Own Now Ceremony
- Skiing in the Alps
- Competing against the young
- Finding confidence
- The value of public universities
- Ruining Lutefisk
- A Christmas Blizzard
- Memoirs
- How do I get noticed?
- Poetry and the Fairer Sex
- Developing a natural voice
- Pentecost
- Boycott
- Anonymous in the Big City
- Thanks to Ford
- Offended
- What happened to that "Sweet Biscuit Fiddle?"
- "Tom and Sally"
- NOTE FROM THE HOST
- SFX Lady??
- Missing The Old Scout
- Live in San Diego
- So Where's Sinclair?
- This is my first big trip away from home. Any advice for a first-time traveler?
- How come the house band is called The Shoe Band?
- October 21 Cinecast
- Getting into the Radio Business
- On the 12th Floor of the Acme Building...
- Going to the Big City!
- 73 Days of Summer Vacation
- Help with a Eulogy
- Where Do I Start?
- Fantasy League Whippets
- Clergywomen in Lake Wobegon
- The more you write, the better it gets
- The Voice
- A Note from GK about Retirement
- Low Self-Esteem
- Useless Degrees
- Car Bomb
- The Dog-Ears of Summer
- Dealing with Disappointment
- Rejection Letters
- English Majors Strike Again
- 7th Grade Report
- GK Responds to Cinecast Posts
Complete Post to the Host Archive
Tom | June 11, 2007 4:24 PM
Holy cow (if one can beatify a cow in this man's presence). Such an extreme reaction to storytelling. If an imagined animal's death causes such a response, it's unsettling to think what happens around his house when he sees stories about what's happening in Iraq, Darfur and other places where real violence is happening.
David, Boise | June 11, 2007 4:36 PM
Wow, if a story of a pastor's wife killing a groundhog is enough to make Jerald "go ballistic," I can only imagine what happens when he gets his utility bills during a cold Montana winter. Do they go "thermonuclear"?
"Killing animals with your humor"? Really? So a PHC knock-knock joke could send a squirrel to its demise? My god, think of the penguins!
Sandy Gilman | June 11, 2007 5:41 PM
I wonder where radical animal
activists stand on cockroaches?
Seems like some people will do
anything for attention!
My husband and I were privileged
to see the show at the Greek.
It was a high point in my life and
I'm far into middle age and have
done some pretty interesting things.
I listened to the show twice -- once
Saturday and once Sunday. Besides a
good book, Prairie Home is the best
entertainment around!!
Thanks for being there (on the RADIO!).
Sandy Gilman
San Clemente, CA
Greg McPherson | June 11, 2007 9:31 PM
Dear Garrison,
I would certainly hope that just because one "world traveler" does not like a good story with accurate details in it, that you would even consider quiting live radio. I know that is not what you said, but one must be prepared to fight for the things they really beleive in. I for one beleive that a radio show host of ones character would surpass anyone persons need to complain about anything that host decided to bring to us. As a matter of fact, I am quite fed up with people chimming in every so often to tell you how to run your show or to tell you that you said something that hurt thier little feelings. Well hear this, I am going on record to say that the next person that complains in anyway shape or form must first supply to you with proof that thier radio show would be a better representation of American life than yours!
Greg and Sandra in Michigan.
Larry Y. | June 11, 2007 10:27 PM
It's a story! Good stories mirror real life. You did not like the material so you turned off the show. Yet you live in a state where hunting is the norm. Well, I'll still listen to the show and continue to wonder about the human condition.
John Carpenter | June 11, 2007 10:30 PM
Your response reminded me of an occasion when I was asked to fill in on a panel discussion about violence in the mass media. All I was was a young reporter not used to getting up in front of people. And I became more nervous when I realized it was a rather large crowd of very passionate people. You might say they were the kind of folks who might "go ballistic" at a friendly radio show. My bacon was saved, though, by our very talented and straight-talking movie critic. "There is," he started, "no such thing as violence in movies!" There was general murmuring and shaking of heads. And he continued. "What there is is PRETEND violence." I was smart enough to sit back and let him handle the session.
Happy Father's Day, Garrison, if you don't mind me calling you Garrison. Now I have to get back to answering my e-mail, most notably a note from a parent who's upset that our little league team is playing a playoff game on Father's Day. To each her own, I suppose. But I can't imagine many better Father's Days than watching my kid play baseball under a clear June sky (knock wood) in Michigan.
Richard Stephens | June 11, 2007 10:54 PM
Mr.Keillor
I just read the letter from the person complaining about your humor involving the death of animals.
Obviously, this self appointed guardian of animals is not very perceptive or he would have known you often are making fun of the hunters instead of the animals.
I'm sure my views on hunting are very different than yours, but I love your humor no matter who the victim is, man or animal. It is true that there is a large number of people who believe animals and plants(trees especially) should never be harvested, but that just can't work.
I don't want to debate that, but if I did there is plenty of evidence in the Bible to support the outrageous idea that animals AND plants were put here for our use.
I appreciate your genius in bringing humor to everyday life situations. I know you won't let anyone deter you from being yourself.
If any such person should "go ballistic" I'm sure your quick thinking could turn it around and put him in his place. In fact, why not rehearse for such an occurence.
Good Luck,
Richard Stephens
Sue G | June 12, 2007 9:39 AM
What an absurd statement. The shooting of the Groundhog was part of a STORY for heaven's sake. These are the same type of folks who want the Woodsman, Little Red Riding Hood and the Wolf to all live happily ever after.
Jim Stacho | June 12, 2007 4:07 PM
Something about shows from Hawaii seems to elicit the dumbest complaints. Earlier this year, it was someone who complained that his NPR contributions were being frittered away by the glamorous touring schedule of PHC to places like Hawaii (I'm sure NPR does not pick up the tab for GK's airfare or any other creature comforts). Now, we have Jerald getting fevered over the deaths of make believe animals in fictitious stories. Hope he doesn't reading The Yearling by mistake.
Dewey | June 16, 2007 5:21 PM
I don't go around hunting animals and I don't berate anyone who does. I do eat hamburgers and fried chicken so it is killing/death by proxy when ordering up a burger.
I do get upset when people kill horses or cows because they want to shoot something for no other purpose than to shoot it.
Shawn | June 18, 2007 9:17 AM
Garrison,
I want to tell you that I enjoyed your story and not to mind some animal rights idiot going ballistic. Live radio is alive and well thanks to people like you.
I am a conservative (bordering on libertarian) so you can imagine how many times some of your jokes have tramped on my beliefs. This is one of the main differences between liberals and conservatives. We know how to laugh at ourselves. Perhaps some future news from Lake Woebegon will be about how an animal rights activists group came and protested the pastors wife's indiscriminate groundhog murders!! And this from a Christian woman. LOL