Post to the Host
Host Garrison Keillor answers your questions about life, love, writing, authors, and of course, A Prairie Home Companion.
March 27, 2007 | 3 Comments
Post to the Host:
It's the 3/24 show I'm listening to through increasing static (due to some atmospheric deviltry) as I feel obligated to comment.
I loved the reference to Samuel Colt (special thanks to Fred for the spinning cartridge magazine) but you left a little to be desired in the area of differentiation between the most basic of firearms. Remington does make a 30-06 but it is by no means a shotgun. We're talkin' rifle here. The 30-06 might be a decent choice for game some distance off like deer although most might want a larger caliber for something with the ability to acutely form a grudge such as bear. A shotgun is the weapon of choice for occasions of a more 'up-close-and-personal' nature... like weddings.
Have a blessed day,
Mike R.
Ann Arbor
You're dealing with dummies, Mike, so when I wrote "thirty-ought-six" into the Guy Noir script for Barbara Barbara to shoot the bear with as she walked the mountain path with Harrison Ford ("the big sissy") I was operating from some old memory of something I heard somebody say once. And it sounds good "thirty-ought-six" so I typed it. Okay. It played well with that New York audience, none of whom has ever put finger to trigger (probably), just as I haven't since I was 12. But I will defend my script. (My obligation as a writer.) Barbara Barbara and Harrison Ford were hiking in the mountains and the grizzly came upon them by surprised. NOWHERE IN THE SCRIPT DID IT SAY THEY WERE OUT FOR BEAR. They might've been out hunting ground squirrels for all we know. She raised the rifle to her shoulder and she shot the grizzly in the eye and killed it. SHE DID THE BEST SHE COULD WITH WHAT SHE HAD. I could've put a slingshot in her hand with a sharp stone and I could've had her shoot
the stone and hit the grizzly in a CERTAIN PLACE UNNAMED ON THE RADIO BUT UNDERSTOOD BY ALL MALE LISTENERS and brought the bear moaning to its knees where she could have popped two Libriums into its gaping maw and given herself and Harrison plenty of time to skedaddle. Life, Mr. Robbins, is all about doing the best you can with what you have. That valiant woman only had a 30.06 cradled in her sinewy arms and, surprised by the behemoth, she raised it and with amazing accuracy, hit it in the eyeball. This often happens on our show. I could've given her a bazooka or an anti-tank weapon or a laser sword but I chose not to. I hope this answers your question, which, now that I look at your letter again, I see you didn't ask okay, I hope this explains my method, and I hope it doesn't irritate you. I do not want to get on the wrong side of a guy who knows this much about guns.
3 Comments
Leave a comment
|
Previous Post: |
Next Post: |
Post to the Host Archive
- Intro to Storytelling
- Birds of a feather
- Poetry 101
- Shave and a Haircut...
- One of Us
- Slow Down and Look Around
- Home Again
- Content and its Discontents
- The Dales
- GENERATION NEXT
- THE FOUNDATION FOR GREAT SUCCESS
- WE ALL SCREAM FOR ICE CREAM
- NOTHING BEATS BROWSING
- Lake Wobegon Screenplay
- English Majors
- No Time for Rhyme?
- Sheko Hariir
- Fair is Fair
- Absorb Your Surroundings
- Sitting Around the Campfire
- Overshadowed and Choked Out
- Lake Wobegon Factbook
- Just Good Manners
- Lake Wobegon Census
- A Sobering Sight
- Strange Interference
- Flannery O'Connor
- An Artistic Move
- It Wasn't Bad
- Regional Child-Rearing
- No News is Bad News
- Earl Sanderson, Eagle Scout
- F-Stop Ftizgerald
- Please Advise
- Get Sauk Centre Centered
- Did You Hear the One About...?
- He Should Pay It, Not You
- Goose V. Gray Duck
- Deals in Stereotypes
- Not Fade Away
- Jeepers Creepers, Where'd Ya Get Those Peepers?
- The Old Man Would Be Tickled Pink
- John Updike, 1932 - 2009
- Try to Do Things Right
- The Ice Storm
- The Department of Folk Song
- Having Fun with Mr. Bush
- The Inauguration
- Maybe Tap Dance
- US Airways Flight 1549
- The Religious Life
- The Future of Radio
- Fragile, In Other Words
- Time to Go Forward
- Troubles You Don't Need
- The Old Scout
- The English Major, Of Course
- The Lake Wobegon Songbook
- A Cure for the Hiccups
- Sweetness Trumps Correctness
- I've Heard about this -- Cat Juggling!
- Antarctic Home Companion?
- Paging Mildred Glick
- The Not-So-Mysterious Origins of Guy Noir
- Best Anti-PHC rant of 2008
- Unpleasant People
- Heroic Parenthood
- Nothing Like It
- How About Lively?
- The Bramble and the Rose
- You Deserve No Less
- Walt is Out There
- Back in the Stacks
- Observations from The Great Gatsby
- Which Means What it Means
Complete Post to the Host Archive
Mary Armstrong | March 27, 2007 11:13 AM
Greetings, all
After reading the discussion about guns and the bear, I'll I could think of was the New Christie Minstrels' version of "The Preacher and the Bear" song. The preacher had a gun with him (on a Sunday, no less!) and although he was brave enough to shoot some undersized rodentry, dropped it and ran like some brainless bunny for the nearest cimmon tree (whatever a "cimmon" tree is I don't know) when he met the grizzly bear and tried the power of impassioned prayer instead. Like the preacher, I would also have abandoned gun and skedaddled, which only goes to show that it doesn't matter what kind of firepower you have, if you don't have the knowhow or fortitude to use it. Fortunately for Harrison Ford, Barbara BarBARa did.
Best regards,
Mary Armstrong
Chet G | March 30, 2007 10:09 PM
I'm puzzled by Mike R's comment about a 30-06 not being a shotgun. It isn't. But the script never says that it is:
"Shot that in Montana. Thirty-ought-six Remington. Just north of Glacier Park. Me and Harrison Ford the big sissy. The grizz came up suddenly — out of its den — we were on a narrow trail — a switchback — five-thousand feet up — sheer drop — it was March — there was a cold mist — suddenly this ten-foot bear looms up like a Mack Truck — and Harrison jumps behind me and I shot it — right in the eye. "
Where is the reference to a shotgun? I heard this show, and nothing sounded out of line to me.
Ben Moses | March 31, 2007 7:31 PM
Garrison - a further nudge on the thirty-AUGHT-six reference - "aught," not "ought." "Aught" means "zero, nary a one," and I ought to know, since I own one (distant antecedent: a thirty-aught-six, stay with me), and that's how my father's father wrote it back in aught-eight when he noted in his dairy (or is it diary?) that he traded two good mules for it - animals, not shoes.
Although my father actually used it, the aught-six, I keep it only as protection, since it's illegal to fire anything larger than a Zippo lighter here in Los Angeles. But I enjoy knowing it's handy on the rear of the top shelf of the bedroom closet well-hidden under some winter clothes (placed for display only), and in an emergency, such as a dastardly Canadian breaking in in the middle of the night in search of ice, I have mastered a plan:
Awakened by Rocky, our guard Rottweiler, I will quickly grope for my car keys and wallet in the dark, either on the nightstand or in the pocket of my pants hanging in the closet or tossed across a nearby chair; then using the bedsheets I'll lower myself out the bedroom window and down one flight next to the kitchen door.
I'll quietly let myself in the door, tiptoe down the stairs to the garage under the house, activate the garage door opener, fire up the Jaguar, and drive the few miles to the all night bakery and ammo store, where I'll purchase enough bullets to render harmless the intruder, speed back into the garage, up the stairs, out the kitchen door and up the bed sheet to the bedroom, get the bullets in the rifle and scare off the Loonie-pinching alien before he has time to figure out what's happening to him.
But wait, the only key to the kitchen door is hanging near the door INSIDE the house. Dad's big thirty-aught-six might not be useful in an emergency after all.
Maybe I need a handgun.