Trading Floor

The Trading Floor features comments, feedback and insight submitted by Marketplace sources. Help advise us about stories we’re working on, discuss the news of the day, and share your insight by joining the Public Insight Network.

FEATURED QUERY: Do you rely on tips for a living? Tell us more

RSS

Discuss

What's the worst piece of financial advice you've ever gotten?

Query
  • Posted by Alison Brody
  • on August 17, 2010 12:17 PM

When it comes to financial advice, Marketplace Money is usually in the business of highlighting the good stuff. This week, however, we’re after the bad. We want to hear the absolute worst, most awful pieces of financial advice you’ve ever gotten.

Tell us here.

Maybe your uncle Larry convinced you to invest in a company that went bust, or perhaps it was a financial professional that led you astray. In this case, I’m sure reality is better than anything we can come up with, so click here to tell us your story.

And, who knows, your tale of woe may save someone else from falling into the same trap.

Discussion: 12 Comments

  • Posted by Susan Christie on August 20, 2010 9:42 AM

    NO ADVICE! On the way to the tech stock decline, I went to visit my financial advisor who worked for a large, reputable firm in the upper midwest. As in previous times, I had seen early indicators that there was a change on the way and wanted to talk to her. She avoided my direct questions preferring to show me toys on her computer she used to watch the market. It was a wasted hour, but told me to make my own decision. I opened an E*Trade account that day, instituted the transfers and wrote her a letter regarding my decision. I did not totally avoid the downturn but was able to save a portion of my money. The next advisor, a change from commission to fee based was better but some of the same problems remained. I now use Vanguard and do it myself!

  • Posted by Tim Hofmann on September 1, 2010 8:21 AM

    ‘Buy a house!’

  • Posted by Diana Maxwell on September 4, 2010 9:09 PM

    Go into data entry as a career. Computers are the future so the world will always need people who know how to punch cards. I didn’t take the advice, but it was still bad advice even in 1975.

  • Posted by Willie on September 9, 2010 12:15 PM

    That the stock market was a safe investment.

  • Posted by Bobby on September 10, 2010 3:14 PM

    My Mom telling me to put money into CDs and bonds. After I discovered e-trade in college and understood the inherent risks in stocks, I also came to realize at least three times the gains of an annual yield from CDs and haven’t looked back since.

  • Posted by Anna Rounseville on September 27, 2010 2:26 PM
     I lived through my parents excesses of the 70's. They were "millionaires on paper". However they did it with total disregard for the priorities needed to maintain a family and a home. They we're successful in their adventure to a point , but unsuccessful both as a married couple, and as parents at that point. Having spent nearly 2 years in a foster home, my Dad got custody, in the early 80's- so you know some things weren't right in the house to start with. They were so focused on bringing in the Almighty Dollar that they kinda forgot about networking with a local church at all and doing things simply. My grandparents, both sets, lived through the Great Depression. My grandmother saved some paper..., was careful, but they always had enough. Perhaps this country wide recession is a wake-up call for living simply and with-in one's means. I also wish someone would have explained the benefits of a 15 year mortgage. We have a 30 and had to restructure even that. It may take some time to pay it off. But we'll manage.
    
  • Posted by Jared Solomon on November 10, 2010 10:11 AM

    The worst financial advice I’ve received was from the financial aid department at every university I’ve attended. That was “student loan debt is good debt”.

    In 7 years of college, I saw tuition double. In 4 years of medical school, I saw tuition rise at greater than 10% a year, every year.

    At no point did anyone seem to be accountable to me for the cost of education. Also, at no point did anyone care to really educate me about the true predatory nature of the current student loan environment.

  • Posted by Victoria Kidd on November 20, 2010 6:04 PM

    I purchased a home about three years ago. The market had already started to slide, and I believed that the home I purchased was already undervalued. The real estate agent and a separate advisor indicated that “real estate is always a sound investment.” I am now staring out my window at two foreclosed homes that are not only much larger than my house, but selling for much less than what I paid for my home.

  • Posted by Carol Larsen on November 28, 2010 11:49 AM

    It was what I wasn’t told! We lost about half of our stocks and bonds holdings in the 90’s because we weren’t paying attention, and apparently neither were either of our brokers. We had no warning. Bein fast learners, however, we got out of stocks except for more conservative and risk-averse issues with a trusted agent. Never did recover, however, and don’t expect to. Whom do you trust? Yourself. It’s your money! By the way, we contribute to about 25 organizations, humanitarian, political, common good, etc. and have never regretted one cent of it, even though we backed a few losers in the political arena, especially lately!

  • Posted by Independent Stock Investing on December 15, 2010 1:33 PM

    Invest in some barely known, supposedly fast-growing penny stock.

    Alas, advice like this is rampant. What’s even more disturbing is people actually acting on this advice. In fact, people seem to do more research buying an automobile or a dish washer than a stock.

  • Posted by ESW on April 25, 2011 7:08 AM

    Buy Enron Stock….

  • Posted by Joe Templin on May 11, 2011 6:37 AM

    “Trust your employer to take care of you.”

Inform the news

Overheard on the Trading Floor